Blog

A promising partnership between the state of California and the Winnemem Wintu Tribe is on the brink of collapse. Despite Governor Gavin Newsom’s high-profile 2024 salmon strategy, which spotlighted the tribe as a “co-equal decision-maker,” state funding for the restoration of winter-run Chinook salmon is drying up.

Here is a breakdown of the current situation:

Two years ago, the Newsom administration celebrated a historic effort to return endangered salmon to the cold, ancestral waters of the McCloud River, upstream of Lake Shasta. Today, tribal officials feel abandoned.

The Tribal Perspective

• The “Betrayal”: Gary Mulcahy, the tribe’s government liaison, described the sudden withdrawal of support as a “betrayal,” stating it feels as though the state has simply given up.
• Economic Impact: The end of the grant – totaling roughly $6 million since 2023 – has triggered immediate layoffs and the loss of tribal jobs intended for long-term restoration.

The State’s Defense

The California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) maintains that the funding was never permanent.

• A “Pilot” Program: Spokesperson Stephen Gonzalez explained that the funds were one-time allocations tied to drought response, designed to test tools rather than provide permanent support.
• Budget Depletion: The state claims the allocated funds have simply been exhausted, despite recent announcements of $10 million for broader salmon projects elsewhere.

The Ecological Stakes

The Sacramento River’s winter-run Chinook are among the most endangered species in the country.

• The Trap: Dams have blocked the fish from high-elevation cold water for 80 years, forcing them to spawn in lower, warmer waters where their eggs frequently “cook.”
• The Solution Interrupted: For a brief window, eggs were successfully relocated to the McCloud River, where they hatched and began their migration. Without funding to transport more eggs this year, that progress stops.
• Genetic Diversity: The funding loss also halts the tribe’s ambitious plan to bring the wild descendants of McCloud salmon back from New Zealand to revitalize the California population’s DNA.

A Crisis of Trust

Beyond the science, researchers like Carson Jeffres of UC Davis warn that “pulling the rug out” from under the tribe causes irreparable damage to professional and cultural relationships.

While state officials call the pilot a success for establishing a “foundation,” the Winnemem Wintu are left with “bare-bones staff” and a dimming hope that their sacred fish will ever truly return home.