Blog

Setting the Record Straight: New Analysis Challenges Claims That Farmed Fish Contributes to Overfishing

Recent reporting in The New York Times has renewed debate over the environmental impacts of farmed seafood, particularly the use of wild-caught fish in aquaculture feed. While concerns about labor practices and sustainability within portions of the global fishmeal supply chain deserve attention, a new analysis by fisheries scientist and seafood educator Emily De Sousa argues that the broader conclusion – that fish farming is making overfishing worse – does not reflect the full picture.

In her article, What The New York Times Got Right (and Wrong) About Farmed Fish, De Sousa examines the claims surrounding aquaculture’s reliance on wild fish and highlights significant improvements in feed technology, sourcing practices, and production efficiency.

One important distinction is that aquaculture encompasses a wide variety of species and production methods. Not all farmed seafood depends on fishmeal or fish oil. Shellfish, seaweed, and certain other farmed species require no manufactured feed, while advances in nutrition have substantially reduced the dependence of fed species on marine ingredients.

According to the article, global aquaculture produced approximately 103 million metric tons of aquatic animals in 2024, representing 53% of total aquatic animal production. Meanwhile, wild capture production has remained relatively stable for approximately three decades. Nearly all growth in global seafood production since the 1990s has come from aquaculture, helping meet increasing consumer demand without placing all additional pressure on wild fisheries.

Feed formulations have also evolved considerably. Plant-based proteins and oils, algae-derived omega-3s, insect proteins, and other alternative ingredients are increasingly being incorporated into aquaculture diets. Additionally, fish-processing byproducts such as heads, frames, and trimmings are being recovered and converted into fishmeal and fish oil rather than going to waste.

De Sousa notes that in 2024, processing byproducts accounted for approximately 34% of fishmeal and 54% of fish oil production. These developments demonstrate how improvements in feed efficiency and resource utilization are helping reduce aquaculture’s reliance on whole wild-caught fish.

The article also acknowledges legitimate concerns regarding forced labor and inadequate oversight in portions of the global seafood supply chain. These issues deserve continued scrutiny and stronger accountability. However, they are challenges involving sourcing practices, enforcement, and supply-chain transparency – not evidence that aquaculture as a whole is inherently unsustainable.

For California’s aquaculture industry, the broader takeaway is important: responsible aquaculture is an essential component of a sustainable seafood system. Continued investment in research, innovation, responsible feed sourcing, and effective oversight will help ensure the industry can meet future food demands while supporting healthy aquatic ecosystems.

Read the full analysis: What The New York Times Got Right (and Wrong) About Farmed Fish

Post a comment

Skip to content